Morgan Cemetery is burying people in a 15-foot strip between neighbors' backyards and its own road. For eight years there were no graves there. The Township ordered them to stop in April 2025. About 20 more graves have gone in since.
We saw They're laying graves three deep, parallel to our fence, along its full 100 feet. Opinion By our estimate, that's room for upwards of 50 graves against one family's backyard.
–people have signed
Feb. 27, 2025, taken from our backyard: the backhoe digging against our fence post.
15 ftwidth of the strip between our fence and the cemetery road
0graves in that strip from 2017, when we moved in, until 2025
~20graves added there since the Township's notice
50 ftno-burial buffer from property lines in North Arlington, NJ
Common sense
Nobody should have graves dug against their backyard fence.
Opinion This isn't a complicated legal question. It's a question of basic decency, for the families next door and for the families burying their loved ones.
A backhoe at the fence post.Record State law requires about 4 feet of soil over a coffin, so each grave is roughly 6 to 7 feet deep (N.J.S.A. 26:6-36). We saw Those holes are being dug right at our fence posts and footings.
Funerals in our backyard.Opinion Grieving families stand at a graveside a few feet from a family's yard, kids and dogs and cookouts included. Neither family gets privacy or dignity.
Other towns don't allow it.Record North Arlington bans burials within 50 feet of any property line (code). Franklin Lakes requires a 250-foot planted buffer around a new or enlarged cemetery (code). Here, the graves are inches from the fence.
Photos
What it looks like from our yard.
We saw All taken by us from our own property, oldest first. Tap a photo to see it full size.
Feb. 27, 2025. Backhoe bucket digging at the base of the fence.Feb. 27, 2025. JCB backhoe working directly behind the fence.Mar. 17, 2025. An open grave dug right against our fence, with boards laid across it.Mar. 17, 2025. Orange marker flags along the fence; backhoe and crew at the cemetery road.May 3, 2025. Backhoe digging a grave just over the fence.May 3, 2025. Seen through a gap in our fence: a casket going into a grave by the fence. It was a plain wooden box, not a sealed casket.May 4, 2025. Disturbed soil at the edge of the cemetery road, by the fence.June 6, 2025. A car parked on top of a grave in the strip, right against our fence.June 17, 2025. Marker flags and new graves in the strip between the fence and the road.Feb. 21, 2026. A car parked on the strip, inches from our fence.Oct. 26, 2026. New graves in the strip beside the fence.Oct. 26, 2026. Plywood covering a freshly dug grave against our fence, left open to wait for a funeral at a later date.Nov. 3, 2026. Dump truck on the cemetery road; boards over a fresh dig by the fence.Nov. 3, 2026. Open grave covered with boards and a soil pile, next to the fence.Nov. 17, 2026. Visitors' cars parked on the strip along our fence (license plates blurred).
What happened
Eight years of nothing. Then the backhoes.
2017We saw We moved in. The strip behind our fence had no graves. People attending funerals parked their cars on it.
Early 2025We saw Backhoes started digging graves at the base of our fence.
April 7, 2025Record After complaints from neighbors, Cinnaminson Township's zoning office issued a written violation notice. It cites burials without Planning Board approval, without a zoning permit and without the required setbacks from homes.
Since thenWe saw About 20 more graves in the same strip.
NowTheir response As the Township has told us, the cemetery claims the land is "grandfathered," and the Township has not acted further.
Record The Township's notice says the operators "have recently elected, without the required approval from the Planning Board, to utilize perimeter areas of the tract as areas for gravesites and burial places without the required approvals and without consideration for various setbacks distances from neighboring residents."
"Grandfathered"?
You can't grandfather graves that were never there.
Record Morgan Cemetery dates to 1888, before Cinnaminson had zoning. Under New Jersey law, a use that existed before zoning may continue, but expanding it generally needs approval (N.J.S.A. 40:55D-68). The Township's own notice treats these burials as beginning or changing a use of land, which requires a permit.
We saw Cars still park on the strip, right against our fence. In June 2025 we photographed one parked on top of a grave. See the photos from June 2025, February 2026 and November 2026.
Opinion For eight years this strip was a place to park, not a place to bury. Putting graves there now is new use of that ground, and "we're old" shouldn't be a free pass to ignore the Township.
Who's doing this
The operator's track record with human remains.
Record Morgan Cemetery's president is Louis Cicalese (president page). His company, Cemetery Development Company (CemDevCo), manages about 18 New Jersey cemeteries and crematories (Harleigh Cemetery). Here is what public reporting and court records show at cemeteries he runs.
1996 · Rosemount Memorial Park, Elizabeth
People buried under sidewalks, and more than one person in a single grave
News report The cemetery acknowledged burying people under sidewalks (New York Times). The state case also involved multiple people placed in single graves and graves that were reclaimed (lehighvalleylive).
Outcome: a $60,000 penalty paid by the cemetery and its principals, Mr. Cicalese and Lawrence Nikola, as reported.
2017 · Rosemount Memorial Park, Elizabeth
A body left exposed in an unfilled grave
News report NJ.com reported a body found exposed to the elements in a grave that had not been filled (NJ.com).
Outcome: the state Division of Consumer Affairs announced an investigation. No published result found.
2018–2020 · Washington Cemetery, Warren County
Human remains and casket debris found unearthed
News report In 2020, old human remains and casket debris were found at the cemetery. Families complained of new graves placed among existing plots, and the Borough said a road was built and soil moved without local permits (lehighvalleylive).
Their response Vice president Michael Baratta wrote that photos showed storm damage before cleanup and that "memorials have not been bulldozed."
Outcome: the county prosecutor called the remains discovery accidental, with no crime found. Two Cemetery Board investigations were reported open in 2020, with no published result found.
2018–2026 · Ruffin Cemetery, Tinton Falls
Hundreds of strangers' remains in a family's historic cemetery
Allegation, not proven Descendants of the Ruffin family, joined by the Borough of Tinton Falls, alleged in court that hundreds of remains were buried in the small historic cemetery since 2018 without the family's authorization (News 12, 2023). In 2026 a descendant was still fighting to have the remains of strangers removed (News 12, 2026).
Their response Mr. Cicalese's attorney disputes that the family owns the land.
Outcome: the lawsuit (MON-L-1120-23) was dismissed after trial in August 2024 for lack of proof of ownership. The court did not decide who owns the land.
2012 · Washington Cemetery, Warren County
A bid to add 125 acres to a cemetery
News report CemDevCo applied for a use variance to expand Washington Cemetery by 125 acres (lehighvalleylive).
Outcome: the application was withdrawn before the hearing.
Other than the 1996 penalty, we found no court or regulator finding against Mr. Cicalese, and no criminal charge. Allegations are not proof. Online records are incomplete, so please check the linked sources yourself.
What we're asking
Stop the burials along our fence lines.
We, the undersigned, believe it is wrong to place new graves directly along the property lines of neighboring homes. We ask Cinnaminson Township to stop new burials along residential property lines at Morgan Cemetery, and to act on the Township's April 7, 2025 notice on perimeter burials at 1100 Cinnaminson Avenue.
You don't have to live in Cinnaminson to sign. The signed letter goes to Cinnaminson Township officials.